"American Experience" T.R.: The Story of Theodore Roosevelt (Part I) (TV Episode 1996) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Good documentary
briandaniel6716 January 2006
The title is actually, "TR: The Story of Theodore Roosevelt." It is part of PBS's American Experience series.

I enjoyed it, even though it runs around 4 hours. TR was an especially energetic president and would most likely be an Independent today. He romanticized war (a Republican characteristic), but supported labor (Democratic). He was chauvinistic, but a conservationist and did more to preserve land and parks and animals than probably anyone.

Grubin (the director) left out a good deal of history, but at 4 hours I suppose he had to leave out a lot. I recommend supplementing this documentary with a few biographies beforehand.

Also, this film tends to err on the side of "the good TR," rather than one we might disapprove of. Still, it's a good work and I recommend it.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Balanced Review.
rmax30482328 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Theodore Roosevelt was born into an aristocratic New York family, was troubled by asthma as a child, and grew up believing in personal strength and will power, as his father did, and he adopted the active and somewhat reckless life style of his Southern mother. Some of the talking heads would have agreed with Alfred Adler that he spent his life compensating for that constitutional weakness.

He may have been a sickly kid but in Partd I and II we see him grow into a boisterous and willful man. Not only was he never afraid to impose his will on other individuals -- or other nations for that matter -- he eagerly sought a war with Spain because, as his writings make clear, he embodied the values that General George S. Patton expressed when he said: "All REAL Americans love the sting of battle." Parts I and II cover T.R.'s life up to and including his second term, the first having been "accidental", when President McKinley was assassinated. Unlike some of his predecessors he loved The Bully Pulpit and was arrogant almost beyond belief in his foreign policy. I mean, the guy offers to buy a six-mile strip of land through an isthmus belonging to Colombia for ten million dollars. The Colombians, whose land this is, after all, say no, it's not enough. So Roosevelt, who had put down rebellions in Panama earlier, backs a friendly rebellion this time and, lo, the Panama Canal. Speak softly and carry a big stick. I mean, if Ernest Hemingway had been a president, this is how he might have governed.

Yet his rough handling of the rest of the world didn't extend to the citizens of his own country, especially the poor, for whom he felt a kind of noblesse oblige. He not only busted the trusts that stifled competition and put all the power in the hands of Wall Street, he began by taking on J. Pierpont Morgan, one of the most powerful men in the world. (He owned more gold and silver than the United States government.) Roosevelt won the battle too. It occurred to me, watching this, that one of the reasons T. R. took on this giant of industry was not only out of any sympathy for the poor but also because he WAS a giant. Why kill a mouse?

All these contradictions -- if that's what they are -- are brought out in Part I and handled with a delicate balance.

The minor information is kind of interesting, especially to kids who don't know anything about it, such as the fact that T. R. refused to shoot a black bear cub while hunting in Mississippi, and an enterprising toy manufacturer in Brooklyn began turning out best-selling stuffed animals called "Teddy Bears." Some of the observations are humorous too. The Democrat who ran against T. R. in a hopeless race, is described as so colorless as to "have all the salient features of a sphere." (Well, I found it funny, anyway.) Part I ends with Roosevelt's much-regretted promise that he would honor George Washington's example by not running for another term. Wow -- what a mistake.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The first portion of a great biography on a very, very important American.
planktonrules9 September 2011
This is part of a multi-part series on the life of Teddy Roosevelt from the PBS series "The American Experience". Considering what a complex and amazing man Roosevelt was, it's actually surprising to me that it took this long for the series to feature his life. It's not surprising, then, that the total story of his life was stretched out to nearly four hours--and could have EASILY been much longer.

The show was narrated by Jason Robards and features a variety of interviews--mostly by various grand and great-grandchildren of the man as well as a group of historians. And, along with these, a LOT of stock footage and family photos were used. Together, they did a great job in telling the story.

I do have a few small quibbles with this first portion--and it probably comes from my having read David McCullough's wonderful book about the early years of Theodore Roosevelt. So much that I loved about the book was not in the show--such as the possible psychosomatic basis of his asthma, his exploits while at Harvard and his reaction to the deaths of his wife and mother on the same day. I do understand why the show didn't go into all this--after all, it had to trim a bit to get the story told in its allotted time. But I sure would love to see a show based on the McCullough book (McCullough, by the way, did take part in the show and you see him interviewed several times). I think I wanted to see more of this because it really helped further explain the formation of his character and helped mold him into the great man that he was. I also was a bit surprised how quickly the film talked about Roosevelt's famed charge up San Juan Hill--there was MUCH more to it and lots of interesting yet insane aspects to it that weren't mentioned (such as this cavalry unit not having room on their hastily assembled boats for most of their horses!!).

It's a testament as to how good this show was that in spite of going too quickly through his early life that I still think it earns a 10. A superb show about one of the most complicated and interesting Americans in history. By the way, while quite good, part two feels a bit anticlimactic as you watch--though it's still very, very worth seeing.

By the way, at the 63 minute mark, look for the political cartoon featuring a bound Roosevelt being drug along with McKinley's political parade. It's really quite funny--and rather cute. Also, the images of J. P. Morgan later in the episode were VERY unusual. While it was not mentioned in the film, images of Morgan that were not retouched are very rare. This is because he had a disgusting nose--truly wretched looking due to Rhinophyma and because he was so incredibly rich and powerful, he had pictures of him fixed to hide this. An odd but true fact.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed