The Daughter of the Regiment (TV Movie 1974) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A wonderful cast giving their all in this Donizetti masterpiece
TheLittleSongbird20 July 2011
I love The Daughter of the Regiment(aka La Fille Du Regiment) for many reasons, especially for the amazing music. This is an excellent production, I agree the costumes and sets while not horrible are rather cartoon-ish. That said, I would be struggling to be criticising anything else. The video directing is good, as is the staging and lighting, while the orchestra and conducting are spot on. The story is still entertaining and the characters appealing. In a titular role that is absolutely perfect for her, Beverly Sills is just brilliant, William McDonald is a charming Tonio and Spiro Malas(long time, no see) is hilarious.

In conclusion, Donizetti's opera masterpiece is splendidly done here. 9/10 Bethany Cox
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Beverly Sills In Her Element: Comedy And Opera Merged As One
FloatingOpera75 April 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Wolf Trap Performing Arts Center is located in rural Virginia and this summer 1974 performance of Donizetti's comic opera stars Beverly Sills, who at this time had garnered fame and success as one of the few American opera singers to make it big. This was originally a French comic opera but it has been cleverly written in English. Beverly Sills shines as she conjures Lucile Ball's spirit to portray the lovable, tomboyish orphan who is adopted by a Napoleonic army. She has a genuinely good time playing this role, and she sings beautifully, with stupendous high notes and lyric pianissimi. Her co-stars- tenor William McDonald, baritone Spiro Malas and mezzo-soprano Muriel Costa-Greenspoon, are terrific in their respective roles. Mcdonald is no Pavarotti (who was the better Tonio) but he is cute and sings with elegance and charm, portraying Marie's boyfriend as a kind of lovable goof. Spiro Malas is hilarious as the grumbling and fatherly Captain Sulpice. Muriel Greenspoon plays the part of the Marquise as a joke of a bourgeois woman. Marie's Singing Lesson is sheer comedy. As this is sung in English, and the dialogue is full of funny lines, it often has the feel of a Broadway musical or Gilbert and Sullivan operetta. For fans of Beverly Sills, this is a real treat. She could sing La Fille Du Regiment with great flair and she totally enjoyed the role, whereas her rival Joan Sutherland merely sang the role in a pretty, cool manner. The production values are not high, and in fact the sets look like a cartoon and the costumes (particularly that of Sulpice and Sills) look like they are out of a Disney animated feature. But this is a document in the career of Beverly Sills. She has only two other filmed performances - La Traviat and Donizetti's Roberto Devereaux, both performances which followed this one in consecutive summer performances at Wolf Trap.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed