"Babylon 5" Whatever Happened to Mr. Garibaldi? (TV Episode 1996) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Not for the superficial
yincognyto-9171812 May 2018
Warning: Spoilers
The other two reviews on this one suffer from the same flaw: they are superficial (like the nowadays world, I would say). All this while the WHOLE story, characters, symbolism and (most of the) behavior in this show tries to convey a much more complex take on things, using A LOT of allegories on subjects like life, death, morals, feelings, war, peace, and of course ... mysticism (or religion, if you like), nicely packed in a science fiction scenario. From this point of view, this "boring" chat between Sheridan and Lorien is not only necessary, but within the spirit of the show. Babylon 5 was never intended to be an all out action packed series (like many others), but a combination of action and reflection on various subjects that are present both in the show and in present life (sort of a cleverly done mystical Star Trek).

No one mentioned it yet in the reviews, but this is a good episode to notice it: do you think that the year of the first Shadow War (rougly 1260 in Earth time, aka the years of Genghis Khan and the Great Plague, when a great part of humans died), the 1000 years between the first Shadow War and this final one (also mentioned in the Apocalypse, go figure), the "triad" of Sinclair, Delenn and Sheridan (alegory to the "holy trinity" in Christianity), the resemblance of Shadows and Vorlons to the devils and angels in Abrahamic religions (even to the point of the questions they like to ask other races) and a bunch of other things in the show ... are by accident? Cause if you do, you missed the whole point and meaning of the series, and you will of course find the Sheridan - Lorien dialogue "boring"...

Me, I'm not a religious person at all (far from it, I would say), but the symbolism is expertly done to the finest detail, really. Lorien's "low energy" part is from my POV an overly cautious attempt to touch the idea of god (overly cautious because Lorien "can't create life", but can only "revive" beings in certain conditions), and his talk with Sheridan is absolutely necessary to make a fearless, "above all" character from a previously "Vorlonized" puppet, a character who can think for himself and take the needed decisions to separate the younger races from the abusive Shadow-Vorlon interference at the end of the series.

I'm really sorry for those who saw "boredom" and "low energy" in this episode, because as I said, it's both in the spirit of the show AND essential for the future development of the story and characters. Dr. Franklin's "walkabout" is infinitely more boring than this part - at least this HAS A MEANING (both in theory and practice). The superficial ones might have trouble getting the idea though - no offense...
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Like the last episode, this one is pretty vague and the action is quite subdued
planktonrules23 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Like the previous episode, this one is pretty low energy and not a whole lot is accomplished. In many ways, it's like a lull between the exciting climax of season 3 and the soon to heat up episodes later in season 4. Here, the problems of the loss of Garibaldi and Sheridan is the main thrust of the shows, but BOTH are not resolved until the next episode--so some might be a bit disappointed since nothing significant occurs in episode 4.2.

Sheridan awakens in a cave deep within Z'Ha'Dum. He's been here for some time and the last memory he has is of his ship crashing into the planet and detonating some nuclear warheads (which SHOULD have vaporized him). An alien named Lorien appears and discusses this with him and sounds like some sort of nice know-it-all mystic. It turns out, he is the oldest sentient being in the galaxy and he has somehow saved Sheridan from certain death.

At about the same time, on the station, G'Kar is frustrated with the lack of progress in locating Garibaldi, so he decides he must dedicate himself to finding him--even though he has no clue as to where to start. So, being G'Kar, he spends much of his time kicking butt and intimidating people until he has some leads.

The episode ends with Garibaldi STILL lost and Sheridan still stuck on Z'Ha'Dum--and it's not until the next episode when they return to B-5. Generally, the writing and acting are just fine, but I found the nice Lorien also a bit annoying. Apparently all-knowing eternals can be forgiven for being so mystical and sounding like Keye Luke from the show "Kung Fu".
10 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bad idea in a very good show
wilvis-9396321 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Lorien and Sheridan bored the hell out of me as for the rest i would have been satisfied with the dead being dead and someone else take over the station.Not being a very religious person myself the whole idea is just weird.Dead is dead and if not it should not have taken 3 episodes to find out.death by boredom is worse then any other kind of
1 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed