"Combat!" The Short Day of Private Putnam (TV Episode 1964) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The Putnam and Saunders Show
jmarchese6 July 2014
Short Day of Private Putman is a story of a green recruit who lacks the necessary maturity to deal with his squad. And for good reason - he does not belong; an incongruity and anachronism slipped through the cracks.

Private Orville Putman (excellently played by Beau Bridges) pitifully tries to be a seasoned veteran, but it's an act of futility.

Fauvette (well played by Lilyan Chauvin) has some excellent dialog with "Put" and becomes his first reality check along the way.

The rest of the squad get the picture in short order and realize he's green. And Put does not disappoint in proving it out. Putnam and Saunders have excellent on screen chemistry and dialog while Caje is genuinely frustrated and projects it well on screen. In usual form, Kirby is spontaneously sarcastic in a humorous way about Put's exploits.

There's a lot of action and director McEveety does an excellent job with his specialty. I'm only critical of a couple of scenes whereby the German snipers are pitifully poor shots. I would have added two more squad members and lost them in the fray. It would have been well worth it for believability purposes.

Screen writers Esther & Bob Mitchell did a fine job with this one, very believable and even funny in parts. A good analogy highlighting Put in combat would be rookie pilot Lieutenant May running from the Red Baron; the same exact inspiration applies. The ending was beautifully written and well applied to Put the "botanist"; and I vividly remember it from when I was 8 years old having seen the original broadcast. It's fun after 50 years to see it all over again.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the best so far.
abbluesky641 February 2016
I bought the box set of 'Combat' a while back and have been working my way through each episode in chronological order, and I have to say that so far this has been one of the very best episodes I've seen - not least for the wonderful performance of Beau Bridges as a raw 15 year old recruit, suddenly realising that war is not like the comic books.

Men die and the enemy are out to kill you. I believe Bridges was 22 or so when he made this, yet he really does look 15 or 16 years old, and turns in a touching performance of an innocent youth suddenly caught up in a madness he's totally unprepared for. His spats with Saunders and the rest of the troop are totally believable and it's a story that never becomes bogged down, with a nice mix of action and humour.

As another reviewer has said, the one criticism could be the usual poor shooting of the Germans in comparison to the sharp-shooting of the Americans (as snipers you would expect them to be crack shots after all!). 'Combat' was not quite as bad as some series of the time in painting the Germans as poor shots, but they do still almost always die to a man, whereas only the odd American is killed. If only the war had been that easy eh?!

That aside, this is a really fine story, well acted and beautifully filmed. It's a 9/10 from me.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Silly Episode
claudio_carvalho17 September 2017
When the new replacement Pvt. Orville Putnam arrives to Saunders' squad, he tries to pose of an experienced soldier but he does not convince anybody. The French bartender Fauvette finds that Putnam is only a fifteen year-old soldier but when she decides to disclose the information to Lt. Hanley, the teenager is already in a dangerous assignment with Saunders and the squad in a forest with German snipers. How will finish the short day of Private Putnam?

"The Short Day of Private Putnam" is a silly episode of "Combat!". The story of a fifteen year-old boy awarded in botanical study that join the American Army "o find buddies" is not only silly, but also senseless. The guy's attitude is aggressive and pretentious most of the time. In addition, the 23 year-old Beau Bridges does not look like a 15 year-old boy. My vote is seven.

Title (Brazil): "O Dia Curto do Soldado Putnam" ("The Short Day of Private Putnam")
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gotta love that Beau
lor_26 July 2023
It's a treat to see Beau Bridges performing at such a young age, already displaying the charm and natural openness that has graced so many different roles over the years. Frankly, I've always preferred him to far more lauded little bro Jeff in the usual Smothers Brothers type of competition on screen.

Casting the wonderful veteran Lilyan Chauvin opposite him in this episode works marvelously -not only contrasting acting styles but the highly effective age difference.

With VIc his usual "tough love" self in dealing with the foibles of the soldiers entrusted to him to lead, we have an emotionally-charged irresistible little story.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed