"Little House on the Prairie" My Ellen (TV Episode 1977) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Love Lost
mitchrmp16 June 2013
It's hard to imagine what one would do if the only child they ever had was suddenly taken from them. People react in different ways. Some get over it faster than others. Some have a hard time, and others can go crazy. I think this is a mild case of craziness.

I'm surprised Laura and Mary didn't have more guilt over the drowning, but the episode clearly wanted to focus on Eloise, the mother of Ellen Taylor who'd drowned. She cursed God. I thought the cursing the Bible and throwing it has always made me cringe a bit...

Laura's ability to look a lot like Ellen is what made this part of the story believable. Mrs. Taylor dressed Laura and styled her hair to look a lot like her dead daughters. Even Mrs. Olsen did wonderful in this. I think she was genuinely worried about Laura and Eloise.

Again, several people show up in this one episode never to be heard or seen again: The Taylors and Bugsby are long-time residents of Walnut Grove, yet surprisingly silent and unseen for the rest of the Little House years!

Excellent episode with a little bit of action and a lot of love! It'll leave you feeling good at the end.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Teetering Over the Abyss...
ExplorerDS67899 June 2011
Warning: Spoilers
To celebrate this fine summer afternoon, Mary, Laura, Carrie and their new friend Ellen Taylor were going swimming. Eager to get to the lake first, Laura attempts to cut through Busby's yard, but being a buzzkill, Mary had to remind her it was off limits. Strangely, Mr. Busby was watching them the whole time. I guess he's either really bored or a perv. Anyway, so while the girls splashed around and played in the lake, two mischievous boys were hiding in the bushes hoping to catch one of the Ingalls girls naked. They're discovered by Carrie, but naturally she's oblivious to what they're doing and bought their fib about fishing. When the other girls discovered their peepers, they dove under the water, leaving the junior pervs ample time to flee. Mary and Laura emerged to see if the coast was clear and decided it was time to go, but they couldn't find Ellen. Had she not come up too? They called to her, but she didn't respond. That night, a crew dragged the lake and they found Ellen at the bottom. Well, sir, Eloise and Cal Taylor were beside themselves over the death of their daughter. Particularly Eloise, and where do you think this hysterical woman placed blame on this accident? Herself? The water? The boys? Nope, Laura. Um...why? Why Laura? Just because she backed up Ellen's request to go fishing? Geez, how fickle can you get? Reverend Alden came to console Eloise, only for her to get mad at God for not answering her prayers to resurrect Ellen and told the reverend to get lost. The blame train didn't stop there. Next she blamed Cal for being away from home working when Ellen came home. A woman fit to be tied if I ever saw one.

The next day at Hanson's Mill, Charles and Jonathan set to work fixing the water wheel and get it working...with Jonathan still on it. Guess he won't need to take a bath tonight. After that, Reverend Alden stops by to tell Charles of the Eloise situation and suggests Caroline try to talk to her. That didn't work either. Yeah, Eloise was losing it at a tremendous rate. Want proof, here it is: Laura decides to bring her some flowers. After Eloise coddles the flowers, she starts hallucinating and sees Laura as Ellen. Next, she asks Laura to go down to the root cellar and fetch her some apples. The little idiot was more than happy to go down into a creepy, crazy stranger lady's dark cellar, no way could anything bad happen to her... oh wait, Eloise locks her in. Who'd-a-thunk it? When Charles notices her gone, he and Jonathan head out to see Eloise, who denied Laura ever having been there. Next, we finally get to meet that reclusive Mr. Busby, who had apparently been enjoying the things Laura had dropped. When Busby saw them, he flew the coop. A search party is organized, including Cal Taylor with a loaded shotgun. So while the men went about their wild goose chase, that crazy bitch continued to think Laura was her daughter. So much so that she began preparations for her 12th birthday... somebody please just put her out of her misery. Meanwhile, the men finally find Busby...thanks to trigger-happy Cal. Luckily he's a bad shot and Busby was fine, but laid up in Doc Baker's office, where they didn't manage to get much out of him because he was too weak. Again, thanks to Cal. Help, however, comes from the most unlikely place: Mrs. Oleson, who tells about Eloise and the birthday party she was preparing. Thankfully, Laura managed to escape and I guess Eloise snapped out of it when she saw Ellen's grave. And so it all worked out, and Laura and Mr. Busby became friends, even though we'll never see him again, and I guess the Taylors moved out of Walnut Grove, and hopefully into a padded institution.

If dark and dramatic is your thing, look no further. "My Ellen" is a tour de force drama and psychological thriller. It's also got some moments of comedy, like Jonathan and the water wheel to liven things up. The late Corinne Camancho really pulled off Eloise well, as she looked like she was ready to go ax crazy any moment. Also good was Ken Johnson as Busby in an unforgettable cameo. Mia Bendixsen was adorable as Ellen, and of course, all the regulars did a fantastic job too. I think young boys will like the beginning of this episode since Mary and Laura swim in the nude. I guess they didn't have swim suits or long-johns to wear that day, but hey, I'm not complaining. So if you like what you've heard, give "My Ellen" a go.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Trying to be Twisted
Quinn407722 December 2021
Good chemistry between Melissa Gilbert (Laura) and Corinne Camacho as Mrs. Taylor, Ellen's mother. Their scenes together set this episode apart from the other "lost child" episodes on Little House. The character of Mr. Bugsby is introduced and could have served the story better had they developed his character or his relationship to the town more and enough to warrant the screen time and plot participation that he receives. I'm surprised that there isn't a precious episode involving him more clearly.

This episode is trying hard to be twisted and succeeds up until a point. However, Mr. Taylor (Ellen's father) and Mr. Bugsby's roles concerning Laura are not fully developed. Therefore, the episode is frayed and not as solid as it so easily could be.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It's like a psychological thriller!
nomis9422 February 2015
This episode left me speechless. It's so intense and - yes - scary. But in a brilliant and captivating way! The acting is, as usual, really good and I love how consistent Michael Landon dealt with the topic of loss and death. To let go isn't very easy... My goodness, the acting of Ellen's mom is so good and intense, I can't find words! It's also really believable and the directing is clever. After like 5 minutes, something really shocking is happening and that's... wow. An incredible episode! It deserved a total rating of at least 8/10. My rating is 10. But pay attention! It might be a very scary and harsh episode for children. So be careful.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
one of the best and well acted episodes
zledwell-7840524 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I agree with another reviewer. This episode, especially the acting by Eloise(Ellens mom), was unreal. This episode dealing with death and the mental effects was excellent. Melissa did a great job as well! I am surprised that this episode didn't win emmys for content as well as acting. As I watch this series in reruns I realize how wonderful and well put together it was.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The beautiful lady gets a little crazy
gregorycanfield1 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Eloise Taylor is played by the beautiful, drop dead gorgeous, ultra sexy Corrine Michaels. Eloise is distraught over her daughter having drowned. She initially blames Laura for Ellen's death. Eloise becomes so irrational, she starts to see Ellen when she looks at Laura. Eloise actually resorts to holding Laura hostage, seemingly convinced that Laura is Ellen. There was something genuinely touching here. Although Eloise initially blamed Laura for the tragedy, it became clear that she really wasn't blaming Laura. Eloise was so crazy over the loss of her child, she just wanted another child to love. She was wrong to try to hold Laura hostage, but it was clear that she never would have hurt Laura. Besides being such a treat for the eyes, Corrine Michaels was excellent in this role. Very well done, sold episode.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Laura is always promoting, promoting, asking, pushing to do anything...
drfernandogil28 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
The truth is that I don't like surreal chapters, nor when the main character is not in his right mind. What is true is that, although she is not to blame for Ellen's death, Laura is always promoting, promoting, asking, pushing to do anything... Play, swim, build, benefit... Except study of course, She is never seen asking for study meetings... In that sense, she is always annoying and restless. I would say unbearable and capricious... I can say little about Bosly, he is a character who appears very little and is obviously incapable of kidnapping or harming Laura... But he is the main accused and he even gets shot for simply being stupid.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed