User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Wining and Dining while Whining and Shining
WeatherViolet17 November 2009
This episode marks one of the last appearances of, and final television performance by Ina Balin, who has acted in film and on television since 1958. Bibi Besch has also unfortunately since passed.

Sonoma County, California, north of San Francisco, lies within the state's Wine Country region of grape arbors, and contains more than 250 wineries, one of these operated by the Gambini family for generations.

Widower Salvatore Gambini (Eli Wallach) oversees winery production while planning for the future without his family's concern for the business. But now a crime syndicate organization attempts to purchase the winery, which Salvatore intends to keep within the family.

Dedicated daughter Stella Gambini (Ina Balin) efficiently manages domestic responsibilities and is usually seen creating homemade meals from scratch.

Son Marco Gambini (John Saxon) assists his father with the business, while he nor his wife, Fiona Gambini (Bibi Besch), nor Salvatore nor Stella has much influence over Marco and Fiona's three irresponsible young adult children.

Paul Gambini (Thomas Byrd) aspires to play football and often travels with his team although currently on injured reserve to recuperate at the Gambini estate. He secretly meets with Stephen Ridgely (Robert O'Reilly) to plot a course of action when it is determined that a crime syndicate may target him for not yielding to demands to fix a game.

Tony Gambini (Billy Zane) acts very irresponsibly with his family's finances by gambling away not only his funds, but running the winery into debt because of his uncontrollable addition. Now that he owes large gabling debts, the mob also threatens him unless he is able to borrow large amounts from his grandfather to pay back in Lake Tahoe. Before he leaves that morning, Tony falls from a broken basement step, but survives his resulting injury.

Michele Gambini (Kristian Alfonso) has a career position in a San Francisco advertising agency, at which she befriends Ben Skyler (Grant Goodeve), who also has ties to organized crime, which he keeps from Michele in order to accompany her as a guest to the Gambini estate, to the dismay of her family, which questions her willingness to accept a string of unsuitable suitors.

To mark the occasion of the 75th anniversary of the birth of Salvatore Gambini, the family hosts a lavish reception, the invitation list of which includes old friend Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) and Police Chief Thaddius Kyle (Arlen Dean Snyder), who, amid the festivities, discuss Tony's "accident" from the broken basement step.

But the next morning, when a body is discovered in the basement, Jessica and Police Chief Thaddius Kyle investigate the murder, under the notion that at least three members of the Gambini family are sitting ducks as potential mob targets during this, "A Very Good Year for Murder."

The cast is rounded out by Paul Lyell as Guest #1, Jeff Albert as Guest #2, Rob Zapple as Deputy, and John Mooney as Doctor.

Extra points for the performances by Eli Wallach, Ina Balin, Bibi Besch and John Saxon.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Gambini Family Values
bkoganbing3 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This episode finds Jessica Fletcher in the Sonoma Valley wine country of Northern California guest of Eli Wallach, patriarch of the Gambini family of wine growers and merchants.

It saddens Wallach that his son John Saxon nor his daughter Ina Balin, or his three grandchildren, Kristian Alfonso, Thomas Byrd or Billy Zane seem to have inherited his love of the land and the wine business. But they're all together at Wallach's invitation to find some kind of common ground.

A guest that Alfonso brings, Grant Goodeve winds up being poisoned by some of Wallach's product. And it turns out he's in reality a mob hit man.

I go no further but to say in the end Wallach accomplishes his goal.

A most unusual episode with an unusual twist in the end.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An average episode.
Sleepin_Dragon11 March 2021
Jessica is on hand to help The Gambini family, who are under pressure to sell off the Family's winery business.

I think this is a pretty average episode, the story has several holes in it, and Jessica's presence feels incredibly contrived, they just don't seem like a family in her circle.

The mystery is mildly interesting, and the outcome is a little obvious, you should be able to guess the identity of the killer.

We do at least have some good visuals, cars, clothes, and a beefy Thomas Byrd (Paul Gambini.) It's nicely made, and well acted, but it's not in the least bit memorable.

For a family of Italian Americans, they're about as Italian as a Swiss Kangaroo in Peru.

6/10.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Murder in a winery
TheLittleSongbird29 August 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"A Very Good Year for Murder" was almost one of my favourite Season 4 episodes, and it's still a great episode. Marred ever so slightly somewhat by the killer not being that big a surprise in a case with too few suspects. It's a hugely engaging mystery however, with a gorgeous setting, interesting twists, including an unusual and unexpected one at the end.

It is very difficult to ever fault Angela Lansbury in one of her most justifiably best-remembered roles, and she is terrific. Eli Wallach's guest turn is wonderful and the highlight of the episodes as well as his chemistry with Lansbury. The rest of the cast glitter just as much, but not as much as the dominant focus of Lansbury and Wallach, individually and together.

Production values are slick and stylish as ever with 'Murder She Wrote'. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune.

Writing is thought-provoking, light-hearted and amiable.

Altogether, great stuff and very nearly one of my favourites. 9/10 Bethany Cox
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A dying man does what he can to protect his family.
planktonrules24 November 2022
Jessica visits a friend and his family at their wine estate. While the place is very successful and is something for which the family patriarch (Eli Wallach) is quite proud, there future of the place looks hazy. That is because his grandchildren are a sad lot...in particular the youngest (Billy Zane)...a guy who consorts with gamblers and mobsters. In fact, one of them has insinuated himself into the family and what exactly he has in store for them, well, you'll just have to find out for yourself.

The style of this one, particularly the ending, is quite atypical of "Murder, She Wrote". This is NOT a bad thing at all...and considering how similar episodes generally are, it's nice to see something a bit different. Well worth seeing and most unusual.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Jessica Gets A Conscious???
noonieblount2 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Come on....how many episodes have we watched Jessica Fletcher listen to people confess to murder in the name of revenge and with good reasoning, yet Jessica does not sympathize with the killer. However, in this episode not only is a young hitman allowed to infiltrate the family, but he is lured to his death. Jessica gets the confession without the aide of the detective assigned to the case and acts appalled by the confession given. And then at the end she discusses with the detective not only will she not remember what she heard but she may not be available to testify. Oh wow???!!! If calling someone hypocritical was a person during this episode Jessica Fletcher would win the award.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great guest stars elevate this fine episode
shakspryn27 November 2023
Watching this episode made me appreciate what very good actors Eli Wallach and John Saxon, the two best-known guest stars, were. They both add a lot of reality and intensity to whatever film or TV show they are in, and that is true here also. The other guest stars are decent, but it's hard for any actor to match up to the outstanding talent level of John Saxon and Eli Wallach--except for the great Angela Lansbury! Her scene with Eli Wallach are especially strong.

The exterior scenes of this episode are particularly enjoyable, seeing the beautiful wine country estate. We get plenty of episodes with Jessica in New York City, or Boston sometimes; those are always fun, but it's refreshing to journey with her out to the countryside, too.

If the roles filled by Wallach and Saxon had been given to less skilled actors, this would have been a very routine episode, to me. But with them on board, it's superior.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Murder (casually), She Wrote
safenoe30 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
A galaxy of guest stars in this episode: John Saxon, Grant Goodeve, Eli Wallach and Bibi Besch. Strangely not many Italians were cast in this episode, which is populated by the Gambini (not Gambino or Gobbo) family. Anyway, what is somewhat disturbing is the casualness of the murder, and Jessica's blitheness in absolving the murderer of his crime in cahoots with the amenable sheriff. What were the writers thinking?

Anyway, legendary real-life mystery writer P.D. James gets a mention in this episode.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Passable but slow moving
coltras3526 May 2022
A 75th birthday party for a rich Italian wine tycoon (Eli Wallach) ends in murder, but Jessica Fletcher is on hand to unravel the mystery. This is an unusual but slow moving episode that is just passable. It has some moments of suspense but it's not one I would go out of my way to see.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Wallachs, Saxons, Zanes, oh my!
feindlicheubernahme9 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Yep, I'm totally starstruck here. Gramps Eli, Dada John and sonny-boy Bill; how cool is that?!

Unfortunately, the writers also seem to be so dazzled by their guest cast that they forgot to write a good story for them.

The murder victim is a redshirt that nobody apart from the "all male visitors welcome" granddaughter has ever seen before, and even she has only known him for a short while. His death affects no one, therefore we, the viewers, can't really care for the resolution of the case...

... which is just as well, because, in another stunning case of hypocrisy - see "When Thieves Fall Out", as mentioned by another reviewer - Jessica (along with the investigating policeman!) is happy to let the murderer off, presumably due to the fact that he's her good friend. Jess, get it together, girl! You can't just drop the whole "truth, justice, and the Cabot Cove way" ideal every time a crinkly gentleman causes you to have funny feelings in your lady parts.

And a question; why is Wallach's daughter (Saxon's sister) a maid in her own home? Everyone quite literally treats her like a servant. Even at the end, when Wallach is able to receive a visit in hospital, it's his son and daughter-in-law who go in to see him, ignoring the daughter. I know it's an Italo-American family, but we don't need to go the stereotypical Mafia route, whereby women only have significance insofar as their husbands have significance, and unmarried women might as well not exist - outside of the kitchen, anyway.

So, big problems with this episode. Even with that cast list, I would only have given it four stars, but Billy Zane told me in the pub last night to give it five. I listen to my friend Billy Zane. He's a cool guy.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dont watch this one or "When Thieves Fall Out " if you still want to love Jessica Fletcher
mccarraa4 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The Gambini family winery is the takeover target of organized crime and it's up to Jessica to discover who is behind the murder of a Mafia hit man.

A pre-Titanic (1997) Billy Zane guests stars in this episode as one of the Gambini family members.

This is another episode where Jessica is shown to discuss the murderer getting off, due to their victim either being a worse person or because they had a sympathetic reason to kill them; she also did in Murder Takes the Bus.

Ben Skyler was a innocent man, he was a killer. He didn't kill anyone in the show. Salvatore had hired Ben to kill him in hopes of uniting his family against the attempted Mafia takeover of their vineyard, but he nearly killed Tony Gambini instead.
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed