"Please Sir!" Nemesis for Norman (TV Episode 1971) Poster

(TV Series)

(1971)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Truth Will Out?
alanbnew8 September 2021
Potter finally gets his fellow members from an Old Comrades group to let him carry the banner for a parade commemorating El Alamein. He seems to have bored them into submission rather than being a popular choice. He is excited by the event but a visit by his former commanding officer Bell strikes him with worry as he fears his less than distinguished war record will now be exposed.

A very Potter-centred episode with a little interplay with the other staff and the pupils barely featured at all. It's a far from great outing but it has some very unusual and interesting elements. There is a night-time recreation of the fateful battle scene.- quite a bold piece of filming and Potter, his comrades and Bell are shown with their modern appearance rather than trying to portray as they would have been back then. While this may have been done to save costs it probably makes the scene seem more distinctive - these are literally "old soldiers" and the unconvincing attempts to make characters look thirty years younger are avoided. Later the old soldiers, the teachers and the pupils are filmed on the streets as the parade makes its way including some scenes approaching the Royal Albert Hall. "Please Sir!" rarely used location filming so this was very welcome to see.

Among the guest cast is the welcome sight of veteran actor Joe Gladwin, then starring in "Nearest and Dearest" but later in "Last of the Summer Wine". Tim Barrett as Bell was another actor with many comedy appearances although his part here is quite "straight", perhaps to make Potter's predicament more intense.

Questions of cowardice and Potter's war-record are raised. The abrasive teacher and former army man Mr Dix had questioned Potter's record earlier in the series and we could see how this could wound him. Another former army man and fellow teacher Ffitchett-Brown helped Potter on that and this occasion. Unfortunately this was Ffitchett-Brown's last episode with the character moving to work in Malawi. He gave good comedy value - never fully exploited in the show - but also showed himself to be a genuinely likeable individual who really tried to help people. Richard Warwick did a very good job in this role and it's unfortunate he and his character did not stay longer. Mr Hurst and Miss Petting who arrived in the last broadcast episode did not appear here - perhaps there didn't seem room for them in the script given all its wartime and Potter-focus.

Altogether a sign that this last series was very much focused on the staff, often with a particular focus on Potter after the departure of Hedges (John Alderton). Far from vintage "Please Sir!" but one of its most distinctive outings all the same.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
What Did You Do In The War, Mr.Potter?
ShadeGrenade23 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Potter is a member of the local Old Comrades Association, where he bores everyone by blathering on about his war experiences. The only reason he gets selected to lead the forthcoming veterans' parade is that no-one had the nerve to blackball him.

Exactly how true Potter's experiences are will soon be put to the test as his old commanding officer at El Alamein - Bell - shows up at Fenn Street School, demanding to see him.

The caretaker is terrified, and with good reason. Bell is the only man alive who knows that he panicked under fire and fled...

A good Esmonde/Larbey episode, reminiscent of the 'Dad's Army' story 'The Two And A Half Feathers' ( in which Corporal Jones' honour and integrity was under question ). Luckily for Potter, Bell only wants a regimental photo, nothing else.

Very little of 5C here; they appear briefly in a short scene with Smithy but that's about it.

Ffitchett-Brown leaves to take up teaching in Africa. He had not been in the show for very long, and no attempt whatever was made to develop his character or even replicate the relationship Hedges had with the original 5C. Apart from occasionally goosing Doris Ewell, he might as well not have been there.

Joe Gladwin - 'Stan' from 'Nearest & Dearest' and future 'Last Of The Summer Wine' cast member - is one of the veterans.

Funniest moment - Potter proudly marching at the head of the veterans' parade, before leading them down a cul-de-sac!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed