"Doctor Who" The Mind of Evil: Episode Five (TV Episode 1971) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"Sir, I've discharged myself..." Unusual Doctor Who story.
poolandrews6 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Mind of Evil: Episode Five (not 'Part 5') starts as the Keller machine decides the Doctor (Jon Pertwee) & Jo (Katy Manning) don't have enough negative emotions to bother with & instead goes after Mailer (William Marlowe) thus their lives being spared. The Master (Roger Delgado) heads back to Stangmoor after successfully stealing the Thunderbolt missile & convinces the Doctor to take care of the alien parasite inside the Keller machine which is no longer under his control & is becoming a threat to his plans, meanwhile the Brigadier (Nicholas Courtney) has organised a raid on Stangmoor using his UNIT soldiers to regain control. UNIT & the escaped inmates engage in a gunfight while Mailer takes the Doctor & Jo hostage at gunpoint, Jo tackles Mailer but he overpowers her & decides he only needs one hostage so points his gun at the Doctor & shoots...

Episode 9 from season 8 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during February 1971, directed by Timothy Combe I've quite enjoyed The Mind of Evil so far. The script by Don Houghton has been a little complicated & convoluted, I'm certain a lot of plot points were just thrown into it to stretch the story out over six episodes & right now I'm trying to think why the Master invented the Keller machine & for what purpose but either I can't remember or it has never been satisfactorily explained, probably the later as I can't think of a single reason why he needs the Keller machine & since it's out of control why doesn't he just destroy it? The plot is a little bit scattered & we haven't seen or heard anything from the World Peace Conference for ages, tell me again why did the Master kill the Chinese delegate? The cliffhanger ending to this episode is the best one so far in this story. This is an odd Doctor Who & I'm enjoying a silly espionage thriller with a few sci-fi elements rather than a typical Doctor Who story, basically I like it but not as Doctor Who if that makes sense.

The production values on The Mind of Evil have been surprisingly good with decent sets although those stair rails are still wobbling & the 'solid steel' prison doors also wobble a surprising amount! There are several detailed sets, there are quite a few extras, a fair amount of location filming & the end of Episode Five sees an impressive action scene as UNIT storm Stangmoor prison which is pretty violent as UNIT shoot dead several prisoners. The makers were refused permission to film at a real prison so Dover Castle was used as Stangmoor Prison which, somewhat obviously, is why it doesn't look like a prison. I would have thought that The Mind of Evil was a pretty expensive story to make all things considered. The Mind of Evil only exists in black and white but the BBC video tape of the story had a few seconds of colourised clips as I think I'm right in saying that a few seconds of American colour recordings were 'placed' over the black and white 16mm film to give a few seconds of detailed colour clips, UNIT storming Stangmoor at the end of this episode is where the colour clips are from & they look great & while I wasn't minding watching this in black and white these brief colour clips really make me wish the whole thing was in colour & are a tantalising snippet into what it should look like. I'm hopeful the DVD release will be fully re-colourised.

The Mind of Evil: Episode Five is another good part in a good story that I've liked so far. A must for fans & I could also see other more casual viewers enjoying this because of the lack of traditional Doctor Who elements like pointless technical jargon, awful looking monsters & embarrassing special effects.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Major Cosworth, or Major disaster?
Sleepin_Dragon11 January 2019
The penultimate episode in thia rather strong story, I thought, was the weakest episode to date, the once hardened set of criminals are now behaving like skittles for UNIT to pick off, and behaving in a totally incompetent manner, the story has just gone to sleep a little, in favour of action.

Major Cosworth, words fail me, I would love to know where he trained, and just who signed him off as a Major, one would hope that a Major would have a degree of intelligence, sadly Cosworth is nothing short of an idiot. When you compare him to the characters from the first few episodes, such as Chin Li, the story has gone backwards.

Pertwee is a delight though, putting his facial expression talents to great use.

The onlu dud so far. 6/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Mind Bending Plot of Evil
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic25 September 2014
Review of all 6 episodes:

This story starts really well with an intriguing and gritty opening episode and although it fades a little bit by the end it is still overall very good.

The story involves The Master having a mind controlling machine which extracts evil from criminals. It also features a prison take-over, a world peace conference and an attempt to steal a powerful missile. Some of these elements are slightly muddled padding to fill out the 6 parts. Following on from a tight four-parter it is probable that if this one was similarly pared down it would be nearer to top Doctor Who standards rather than just a good medium quality one. Instead, in order to pad things out there is a rather complex and not fully credible plot. The plan hatched by The Master is a bit too convoluted and too reliant on everything going exactly to plan and schedule. As a result it is seen by some as too unlikely as a plot. However, the good qualities of acting, characterisation, action, scary 'monster' (the Keller Machine) and political intrigue all go towards glossing over the relatively small concerns over the plot.

The Master (Roger Delgado) makes for a superb adversary again despite his occasional indecisive ways and Mailer (William Marlowe) is a well acted and convincing henchman. Jo Grant (Katy Manning) is a stronger character in this than in Terror of the Autons (her first story) and this establishes her much better. The Brigadier (Nicholas Courtney) and UNIT are good additional support as ever and there is a gritty prison setting plus exciting military and political elements. I am not a fan of the music and sounds created by Dudley Sutton but accept that at the time they were fresh and innovative and while the incessant noise of the prison riot is very annoying it is more realistic than a quiet riot!

This is a very enjoyable serial; action packed, interesting and well produced. It could have been better but is still a solid adventure.

Episode ratings: Episode 1 - 9, Episodes 2 & 4 - 8.5/10, Episodes 3, 5 & 6 - 8/10 = 50/60

Overall: 8.33/10
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed