"Air Crash Investigation" The Heathrow Enigma (TV Episode 2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Not Quite Making It.
rmax3048239 September 2016
Up to par, this episode has a British Airways 777 on approach to Heathrow in London and experiencing sudden failure in both engines. Through skilled, almost reflexive, airmanship the pilot manages to set the airplane down on the sodden grass just short of the runway, preventing a disastrous crash in the crowded streets of Housrow and stopping a fire from starting. The damage to the airframe was not as bad as it easily could have been, and no one was killed.

When the investigators take up their task of finding the root cause of the accident, it sometimes reminds me of the way the Chinese investigate disease outbreaks. In both cases, the incidents are approached with an open mind, with no prejudice. When the Chinese identified an outbreak of esophageal tumors, for instance, the first thing they did was test the soil, including its temperature. And the same blindly empirical approach is used in these investigations. The engines quit before landing? Okay. Were they out of gas? Actually, the engines weren't out of fuel. Was it the quality of the fuel itself? The origin of the fuel is traced back to Beijing, it's quality tested against more than 1,000 other samples, and it's normal. And so on -- digging deeper and deeper into what increasingly looks like an insoluble problem.

There is a solution, though it's so masked that it took a year to find and correct it. I admire the hell out of the tenacity and imagination of these investigators. I think I might have thrown up my hands and said let 'em die.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Horrible, horrible, horrible
nomad4720029 March 2017
I started watching this episode today, for the fourth time. The glare from every direction, (the sun can not shine from both sides of the cockpit at the same time) was so annoying, I had to turn it off after :17 minutes. I don't recall having noticed it, in my first three viewings.

I don't know why they think that these "special effects" add to the program. It doesn't.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Inaccurate Review of the Findings
m1a2lt8 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
As is quite often seen in this show, the desire for drama and, quite frankly, the anti-American bias is more important than the truth. The show continues to talk about the 100s of B777s in danger and what was wrong with the aircraft. Actually, the problem was with the Trent 800 series engines constructed by Rolls Royce and did not effect any of the Pratt & Whitney or General Electric engines on B777s. A key note that the show doesn't mention is that besides Delta Flight 18, the same event occurred with an Airbus 330 in May 2009 with Rolls Royce Trent 700 series engines. While the show mentions once that Rolls Royce did fix the Fuel Oil Heat Exchanger in the B777 engines (Trent 800s), it doesn't mention that they were also ordered to fix the problem in the Trent 700 series (A330) and 500 series (A340). The implication is that the fault was with the aricraft produced by Boeing which is not true.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed