Expiration Date is a great short. It's beautifully animated, and I personally think it truly captures the personalities of most of the mercs (I wouldn't say that for Sniper and Pyro because they don't really do much). While Scout and Soldier get most of the focus, you can still see snippets of personality from other characters, like Medic's enthusiastic tone when he says "Tumors!", and the part with Demoman right before the title card.
However, a great film is not without its fair share of problems. One first issue I have with this short is that Soldier's stupidity is especially exaggerated. In the early TF2 shorts and comics, Soldier is definitely misguided in some of his actions, but he's not a madman. However, Soldier's lines and actions in Expiration Date are a bit too wacky. They're quite humorous and do manage to get a chuckle out of me, but they're a bit out of character.
Also, the ending is kind of cheesy and contains cliches of the romance genre. It's ambiguous whether or not Miss Pauling likes Scout, which I guess is OK. However, if they do start dating, it would be Überlame because it is implied beforehand on several occasions that Miss Pauling merely tolerates him and doesn't like him back. He did save her life, but if she fell in love with him just for that, that would be kind of generic. All I'm saying is that it would kind of ruin the character development and humorous moments between the two characters that already existed.
Rants about romance aside, Expiration Date is great and I recommend watching it even if you don't play Team Fortress 2.
However, a great film is not without its fair share of problems. One first issue I have with this short is that Soldier's stupidity is especially exaggerated. In the early TF2 shorts and comics, Soldier is definitely misguided in some of his actions, but he's not a madman. However, Soldier's lines and actions in Expiration Date are a bit too wacky. They're quite humorous and do manage to get a chuckle out of me, but they're a bit out of character.
Also, the ending is kind of cheesy and contains cliches of the romance genre. It's ambiguous whether or not Miss Pauling likes Scout, which I guess is OK. However, if they do start dating, it would be Überlame because it is implied beforehand on several occasions that Miss Pauling merely tolerates him and doesn't like him back. He did save her life, but if she fell in love with him just for that, that would be kind of generic. All I'm saying is that it would kind of ruin the character development and humorous moments between the two characters that already existed.
Rants about romance aside, Expiration Date is great and I recommend watching it even if you don't play Team Fortress 2.