Rollermania (2015) Poster

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Remember (Sha La La) The Rollers
Lejink23 September 2015
For my sins I'm both Scottish and was 13 going on 14 when the Rollers became the big teen sensation in Britain, later America of course, which makes me apart from not being female, about as receptive as you could be to them at the time. The group's time at the top wasn't long but it was certainly memorable, remember that no other teen-oriented group here had conquered America since the Beatles in 1964. If you think of groups like say The Herd, Dave Dee Dozy Beaky Mick and Tich, fellow Scots The Marmalade and glam-rockers like T Rex it shows how hard a market America was to break. Nowadays we can see the massive success of One Direction and before that the likes of Wham and Duran Duran but for five young tartan-bedecked lads from Edinburgh barely able to sing together or play their instruments, they must have been heady times.

This Scottish Television production does well to track down most of the major players in the tale, with only Eric Faulkner absent from the group's most familiar line-up to give his version of events today and of course their now-deceased Svengali-type manager Tam (Where's the Money?) Paton later disgraced in a child-abuse scandal. I enjoyed the interviews with the group's hit-making songwriting and production teams Martin and Coulter, followed by Phil Wainman while media-watchers and sometime original participants in their story, from both sides of the Atlantic, most notably Rolling Stone photographer Bob Gruen, try to talk up the Rollers musical legacy (good luck with that) but are better when giving anecdotes of the group at the height of their success.

The four group members themselves make for affable witnesses to their own past success, although you'd hardly say they've aged well in appearance but it was obvious that the producers were playing it safe, with no references to Derek Longmuir's criminal conviction for offences similar to Paton's, no real explanations as to why the band turned over so many group members in a short period of time and last but not least, how Paton swindled them out of the millions their records and merchandising must have made.

Still I guess the aim here was for a loving, light-hearted look back at the dark days of the high inflation, oil-crisis, dole queue infested mid 70's when the Rollers provided some short-lived light relief and helped open up the pre-teen market for succeeding generations of pretty boy and girl bands to part their followers from their pocket money. The songs were catchy and fun, no more than that, although it's amusing to hear BBC pundit Stewart Cosgrove and song-writer Bill Martin try to elevate them beyond their station. I mean how can you defend a line like "Shimmy Shammy Shom, we used to singalong", although I can't deny that even I can't resist punching the air to the chorus of 'Shang-a-Lang!" when the mood takes me.

Fun, disposable and ultimately forgettable (none of the group managed any degree of solo success), I still enjoyed wallowing in nostalgia with The Rollers although I doubt very much if kids today would understand their success. T'was ever thus.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Shang-a-Lang
Prismark1020 December 2015
I recently heard the term 'I have never seen anything like this since The Beatles' applied to some here today and gone tomorrow latest boy band. Which made me think you would have to be over 70 years old to be able to make such a comparison.

The Scots group Bay City Rollers would be one of the few British groups to be able to give the Fab Four a run for its money after they called it a day. Even our household was known to have a few bits of tartan here and there in the mid 1970s.

This production is a comprehensive look at The Bay City Rollers, how they got together with their early management and song writing team who had little faith in the boys. Session musicians were drafted in to lay the tracks on their first album. The later producers allowed the boys more musical input as their success sky rocketed but I always felt their success was more short lived in the UK as by 1977 I never came across them in the pop charts, maybe they were too busy to crack the USA.

Eric Faulkner was a notable absentee in the interviews. The group has had post break up altercations with several Bay City Roller lines ups doing the rounds. Les McKeown talks about how weary he became at the height of their success. Derek Longmuir who famously became a nurse in the 1980s talks about those heady days but his criminal conviction for child pornography is not mentioned.

The band went through a succession of musicians after its classic period and no reason given why the news band members lasted only a few months. Were their tensions with the band or just difficult to work with?

Of course post break up the band members saw little of the money they generated and it is well known they were swindled by their manager Tam Paton.

Still Rollermania is a zippy and frothy look back at the Tartan Invasion outside of a Home International fixture where bands could still be counted on to come up with a few bouncy songs. Even The Ramones stole their riffs.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
"Unabashed pop"
moonspinner553 December 2017
In 1966, two brothers from Edinburgh, Scotland, Derek Longmuir (drums) and Alan Longmuir (bass)--presumably working-class, though that's only intimated--form a band named The Saxons, playing teen dances with minimal success. Once their first single, "Keep on Dancing", a cover song borrowed from The Gentrys, hit the charts in 1971 (and the executives at Bell Records smelled real money), the sonic polishing began, first with new band members except for the Longmuirs and the songwriting team of Bill Martin and Phil Coulter (who contributed the cheerleader-chant "Saturday Night" to the Rollers' first album, ignored in Britain but eventually a number-one hit in the US). It took the pop band quite a while to become "overnight sensations" in the UK and their homeland--and even longer in America, which didn't catch on until 1976--but the pandemonium among teen and pre-teen girls, as well as chart success on both continents, was short-lived. Derek and Alan are interviewed here, as is lead vocalist Leslie McKeown and guitarist-turned-bassist Stuart Wood, but lead guitarist and chief songwriter for the group, Erik Faulkner, is absent. This points up something that Carl Hindmarch's mediocre documentary doesn't wish to dwell over: that internal unhappiness in the band was so strong, one of its most important players won't even talk about the group all these years later. Made up mostly of news footage, the film almost makes the case for non-admirers of the Rollers that they were strictly a fan-phenomenon and not much of a music group. Perhaps the absence of Faulkner meant that the filmmakers could not spotlight the band's musical output, instead putting the emphasis on screaming girls, police barricades, etc. There's a good story here, but "Rollermania" doesn't tell it, excitement in the streets only taking you so far--as the Rollers themselves soon found out. ** from ****
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed